View Cart   My Account  [sign in]

How to select pecans for your pecan pie recipe

About Pecan Pies

More tips on baking, pecan nut selection, recipes, and our story about pecan pies.

Folks at Priester's Pecan Company have a lot of opinions about making a pecan pie. Co-owner Thomas Ellis grew up eating the pies made by his mother May, and helped introduce the pecan pie to Priester's customers in the 1980's. Here Thomas shares tips on selecting the best pecans for your pie.

You can start with pecans in the shell, and then carefully storing pecans for peak freshness and flavor.


Tips: Selecting Pecans for your pie

  • Seek out a supplier who specializes in nuts.
  • "You may be able to find pecans in your local grocery store, but insist on a bright, light-colored kernel that is sweet in flavor. Anything less suggests a nut that's on the way to becoming rancid. Buying from a nut specialist can help you be certain of getting a great tasting pecan."

  • Select the right size pecan for the filling.
  • "Start with medium pecan pieces, or large pecan pieces if available. These are pecans that have been cut or crushed to a certain size. You can use mammoth pecan pieces, and even pecan halves in the filling. But for the best texture, presentation on the plate, and feel in the mouth, Priester's prefers large pecan pieces for the pie filling."

  • Choose heavy-meated pecans.
  • "Eggs are eggs. But with the pecans, you should be extremely selective, as their quality will have a big outcome on the success of your pie. A better pecan is heavy-meated, bright golden in color, and solid in feel. A good heavy-meated pecan that has been turned into large pieces doesn't taste or feel the same as a pecan that's already small and then cut into smaller pieces. Starting from a heavy-meated pecan, the taste is much better."

  • Garnish the top of the pie with halves.
  • "Pecan pieces are nice for the filling, as the pie cuts better with the fork. But for a pie that looks great on the table, place some pecan halves on the top or around the crust."

    Thomas Ellis, co-owner


Prefer to leave the baking to us? See our Old Fashion Pecan Pies, and chocolate pecan pie, too. Explore great southern recipes from our family and friends in "Dining on the Victorian Verandah," the first Priester's cookbook. Or learn about the 510 pie tests it took to make the perfect pecan pie. Feel like cooking up a storm? Perhaps you'd like to enter our Blue Ribbon Good Recipe Contest?