Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies

  • Old-Fashioned Pecan Pie (Gift Boxed)
    Item #107
  • 1 - 9" Pie
  • $27.99
  • Two Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies (Gift Boxed)
    Item #2107
  • 2 - 9" Pies
  • $54.99
  • Two Pies-One Chocolate/One Old-Fashioned (Gift Boxed)
    Item #2100
  • 2 - 9" Pies
  • $54.99
  • Six Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies
    Item #6107
  • 6 - 9" Pies
  • $137.99

Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are a timeless dessert that embodies the essence of Southern cooking. Made with love and a decades-old recipe passed down through generations, these pies capture the comforting flavors of pecans, buttery pastry, and sweet filling.

Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are baked to perfection, creating a harmonious blend of flaky crust and rich, gooey filling. Each bite is a nostalgic trip down memory lane, evoking images of family gatherings and cherished traditions.

These pies are crafted with the finest and freshest ingredients, ensuring an exceptional flavor experience. The star of the show is, of course, the premium pecans. Each pie is generously filled with an abundance of buttery pecans, perfectly toasted to enhance their natural nutty profile.

Whether you're serving these pies at a holiday feast or simply indulging in a slice after a long day, our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are sure to delight your taste buds and warm your heart. Taste the legacy of Southern baking with every bite of these classic and irresistible pies.

What are the ingredients used in the Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies?

Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are made with a combination of high-quality ingredients, including pecans, sugar, corn syrup, eggs, butter, and traditional pie crust.

Do Priester's Pecan Pies ship fresh?

Your pecan pie arrives on your doorstep (or the doorstep of your gift recipient) as fresh as the day we made it. Choose from one, two, or six 9" pies in gift boxes to keep for yourself (we won't judge!) or share with family and friends.

Is it necessary to refrigerate the Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies?

We recommended refrigerating our pecan pies after they've been opened. Pecan pies are considered "egg-rich" pies, and the USDA advises storing them in the fridge to prevent any potential bacterial growth. Refrigerating the pecan pie helps maintain its freshness and prevents the filling from cracking and ruining the presentation!


Write a review - receive 10% Off your next order!

Dec 14, 2023  |  By Kenneth W. Collins
Best pecan pies in the world, my personal opinion. I grew up in the mid-west where pecan trees grew in abundance, so pecan pies frequently appeared as dessert. Priester's Pecan Pies rival those made by my mother.

Really Yummy!
Dec 7, 2023  |  By Katy McCain
So, sad little story... my mom passed a year ago and her tradition to make at Thanksgiving was a chocolate chip pecan pie (we call it a Derby Pie in the South). Well, no one really had time to make that and bring it, so I saw that Priester had this with the regular pie (for those kind-of watching their weight), and so I got it delivered to my parents' home and it was delicious. It really did taste so much like my mom's. Thank you Priester for offering that combo!

Thanksgiving pies
Dec 7, 2023  |  By Patricia Basham
Pies were wonderful. My favorite was the chocolate pecan pies.

Best Pecan Pie
Dec 6, 2023  |  By Carol Anne Lee
The best Pecan pie ever! So many pecans on each pie! The filling is delicious and the crust is not sweet, which compliments the rest of the pie. It's the best Pecan pie that I've ever put in my mouth!!

Best Ever
Dec 6, 2023  |  By Richard W. Boone, Sr.
The chocolate pecan pie is, hands down, the best "store bought" pecan pie I have ever eaten.

Best pies ever
Nov 29, 2023  |  By Marilyn J. Morris
This is the second year I have ordered pecan pies and they are the best tasting pies. My grandson begged me to order but surprise I had already ordered

Nov 29, 2023  |  By Jeanie
The pecan pie was awesome! I would order again. I got it for my husband's birthday! He would rather have the pie instead of cake!

My review
Mar 3, 2023  |  By SUSAN MORGAN
I purchased this pecan pie for my in-laws for Valentines Day. The pie was delicious & it arrived on time as stated it would. I ordered a pecan variant tin for Christmas & my in-laws thoroughly enjoyed it. This time I wanted to send a pie. They were thrilled to receive it. I would recommend these products to anyone.

Great Pies
Jan 4, 2023  |  By Neil L Solomon
My Minnesota relatives loved the two-pie set. My sister-in-law had to keep them under wraps until she brought them out for Christmas dinner. Otherwise, both probably would have been finished as soon as they were received a few days before Christmas.

Dec 8, 2022  |  By Jerry Lackey
Always a good product.

Pecan pie gift
Dec 5, 2022  |  By Mike Blevens
High quality gift product.

Best Pecan Pie Ever
Dec 4, 2022  |  By Lisa Addison
I ordered an Old Fashioned Pecan Pie for our Thanksgiving this year. I was a little hesitant because other pecan pies I have had were way too sweet. This was the best pecan pie we ever had. The Even of sweetness and flavor were perfect. So perfect my extended family debated on who was getting the left over pie. Thank You Priester's.

Priesters never fails
Dec 4, 2022  |  By Susan King
I've been ordering from Priesters for years and have always been 100% satisfied. This years pies for Thanksgiving were delicious. I always buy 3 pound bags of the salted and roasted pecans which are the best for entertaining. The pecans make awesome gifts at the holidays but I use them all year! Highly recommend!

Pecan Pie
Nov 27, 2022  |  By Carol Lee
It's the most delicious pecan pie that I ever had! The crust is not too sweet. It really compliments the filling. There are so many pecans on this pie. It was delivered fresh and perfectly packed! Everyone loved it at Thanksgiving. The second pie is for Christmas. I put 2nd pecan pie in the freezer.

Pecan Pie
Dec 9, 2021  |  By Kristine
Excellent tasting pie. Everyone enjoyed it, although we thought it would be larger.

Oct 23, 2021  |  By Pamela Locklear
The absolute best pecan pie I have ever ate. I follow Brenda Gant and she led me to Priesters! As she says "It's gonna be good y'all!

I'm a kid again
Aug 28, 2021  |  By Rhonda Miller
Living in California, but born and raised in W. Virginia on pecan pies, this pie took me home again and into my childhood memories. Plenty of pecans and sweetness. Boxed well for shipping, so there was no breakage. Arrived fresh and quickly after being shipped.

Best pecan pie ever!
Feb 11, 2021  |  By Pamela Stephan
The pecan pie was absolutely delicious. My husband's favorite. It was packaged perfectly and not a crumb was disturbed on delivery.

Delicious Pecan Pie
Dec 18, 2020  |  By Joan Addison
This was a gift. It arrived in great condition and my friends like it.

Dec 18, 2020  |  By Helena Smith
Too, too yummy!

The Best
Dec 13, 2019  |  By Deborah Firth
What a hit! These pies are huge and delicious. I purchased my first order last year as a gift, they were so tasty we purchased them again this year for Thanksgiving. They also freeze well.

Pecan Pie
Jan 27, 2019  |  By Pam Hobson
Outstanding!!! I send them to people all over the country for Christmas gifts. They always LOVE them!!

Pecan pies Rock!
Jan 16, 2019  |  By Jodi
I give these as both Christmas gifts and surprise thank you gifts. Everyone LOVES them. They also arrive exactly when you schedule them to be delivered. Thanks Priesters for making this such a delicious and unique product!

Jan 11, 2019  |  By FRANKLIN D EDWARD JR
Excellent service!!!!!!

Pecan pie
Jan 9, 2019  |  By Gloria
It arrived earlier than expected. The pie was well wrapped so looked fresh and in good shape when opened. Plus it was delicious!

Great as expected and promised!
Jan 6, 2019  |  By Bigern
Best Pecan Pie I have ever tasted in my 71 years hands down. Been ordering for the past 10 years Thanksgiving, Easter and Christmas.

Pecan Pie
Jan 4, 2019  |  By Jeanne Gill
Packed very well, received right on time, could not improve on the process, and wonderful pie!

Pecan Pie
Jan 2, 2019  |  By Lance McGuire
This is a gift that I send every year to a very dear friend that lives up North. People up north are not very familiar with what we Southerner's enjoy so often, Pecan Pie. Anyway He and his family really enjoy these during the holidays. Priester's Pecan Pies are so delicious and I happy that I can share a little southern joy with him and his beautiful family.

Dec 10, 2018  |  By Joel Phillips
We are so glad we found Priester's. This pecan pie was the best we've ever had. We savored it for a week, only having a small piece each night. Now, we can't wait until next year to buy another one. Thanks, Priester's, for all your wonderful items (the chocolate covered pecans were also great).

Best Pecan Pie in the Land!
Dec 6, 2018  |  By Paul Nelson
We always stop in and pickup treats on our way to the beach and most are gone before we get there, so we have to stop on the way back to reload! We bought pies and shipped them to family and all said it was the best pecan pie they have ever had! Love your pies!

Fabulous Pecan Pie!
Dec 5, 2018  |  By Leigh ann card
It is a tradition we order pecan pies for thanksgiving. This year they were especially good! The mix of pecans and filling was perfect!

Dec 5, 2018  |  By BERYL EASLEY

Great product!
Dec 5, 2018  |  By George Elliott
Excellent product and packaged very well as a corporate gift.

Consistent greatness
Nov 29, 2018  |  By Michelle Carter
I have been a fan of these goodies since I was introduced to them when I moved to Alabama. I am never disappointed with the quality, freshness, and all around deliciousness I have received for the decade + I have been ordering them. Five stars all around!

Love Pecan Pies
Nov 22, 2018  |  By jerry jackson
I order these for my mother, who loves, let me repeat loves these pies!

Blue Ribbon
Nov 4, 2018  |  By A Kay Jefferson
The pie is very good.

Great desserts
Sep 5, 2018  |  By Kay Jefferson
This was the first time I ate a chocolate pecan pie. It was delicious. The original pecan pie was everything I expected.

They loved it
Apr 22, 2018  |  By JJB
Sent the pecan pie as a gift and it received rave reviews.

2 old fashioned pecan pie
Mar 22, 2018  |  By Ruth Dixon
Always Excellent

Mar 15, 2018  |  By Melanie
Excellent customer service! Very personable, friendly and helpful. I was flying from Alabama to Texas to re-connect with a friend from 33 years ago when I found out that Priesters Pecan Pie was his favorite. Because of how soon I had to leave there wasn't time to have a pie shipped to me. The sweet concerned lady that I spoke with helped me locate a distributor close to my hometown and I was able to get a pie the day before I flew out. To ensure the pie's safety, I included it in my carry on bag! Delicious!

Pecan Pies
Jan 16, 2018  |  By Nancy
Best pecan pies. I give 2 pies to my friend that grew up in the South every year. She says they remind her of the pecan pies her family would make.

Old Fashioned Pecan Pies
Jan 4, 2018  |  By Jan Raudat
Delicious for the Holidays-not stale like the last company I purchased from.

Christmas Pie
Dec 23, 2017  |  By Rochelle Allen
My friends in Georgia love their Christmas Pie

Great Pies
Dec 20, 2017  |  By Mary Kalil
These pies were purchased for gifts for my sister and brother for Thanksgiving. I got rave reviews from both. My sister received a pecan and the chocolate pecan and the pecan pie went to my brother's home. I had a piece of the pecan pie which was delicious. I received rave reviews from my sister on the pies I sent to her. Thanks for this opportunity and Merry Christmas to all.

Old fashion pecan pie
Nov 19, 2017  |  By Natalie Posten
This was the best pie my family has ever had!

Southern Girl
Oct 29, 2017  |  By Lauree Bunderson
We ordered one of your pecan pies as a gift for a former southerner, who hadn't had a good pecan pie since leaving the South. She was thrilled with the gift and enjoyed every last crumb!

Jul 18, 2017  |  By Karen B
We bought a couple of the minis at a truck stop. My plan was to freeze them upon returning to Dallas. Well, only one made it to the freezer. I ate the other without sharing with anyone!!!

Good As Always
Mar 28, 2017  |  By Robert Flock
The pies were a gift for my son and he enjoyed them very much. He even managed to take longer than one setting to finish them, but he said they were good to the last crumb.

Golden Pecan Pie
Mar 16, 2017  |  By Cheryle Guillet

Pecan Pie
Jan 25, 2017  |  By Donna Bishop
All my cousin wanted for Christmas was a Pecan Pie and I searched the web and found your company. My cousin said it was the best Pecan Pie she ever had! I guess I will be ordering her another next holiday season. Thank you Priester's.

Awesome gift ideas
Jan 22, 2017  |  By Susan Dalrymple
I bought two pies, one standard pecan and one chocolate and had them shipped to my daughters house at Ft Campbell, Kentucky. They arrived the day I asked them to be delivered, and this was 2 days before XMAS. They did not last until XMAS day....I was told they were delicious and they fought over the last pieces. I am in Portland Oregon and I so wish I could have one of these pies. Oh, and my daughter is quite a baker herself and pecan pie is her favorite pie, so if she thought it was great, it truly must be!

Great pecans & pies
Jan 20, 2017  |  By James Roberts
Pies and flavored pecans were enjoyed by all.

Good Deal
Jan 17, 2017  |  By Chris Shubird
The pecan treats were a big hit with our clients.

A Big Hit
Jan 3, 2017  |  By C. Harris
I bought this as a Christmas gift and got many thanks. It disappeared within two days!

Jan 3, 2017  |  By jim

Those PIES !
Dec 22, 2016  |  By Marie
Unbelieveably yummy!! So good! Just like all the wonderful pecan pies of the past. So many bakeries have "improved" their ingredients or process-- and they aren't as good. We loved them!!

Delicious, but..........
Dec 18, 2016  |  By Wilma Wakefield
The pie was delicious, but the shipping was too expensive.

Pecan pie
Nov 27, 2016  |  By Mark
The best pie ever not a slice left. Will buy again

Old fashioned pecan pies
Nov 22, 2016  |  By Deborah
they were ordered as a gift and they were very excited and pleased

What a hit!
Nov 14, 2016  |  By Jeanie Kilgour
I've ordered from Priester's for years and was very pleased to learn my move to Hawaii wouldn't interfere with that tradition. We went to some friends for an early Thanksgiving dinner last weekend and took a chocolate pecan pie to share with our former southern friends. Everyone raved and raved!

Bobby's Birthday
Sep 12, 2016  |  By Linda
Our son moved to Seattle WA, so to remind him of home we sent him one of your pies for his birthday. It arrived on date requested and in perfect condition. Unfortunately he did not want to "share" any of the pie with anyone else ;)

Excellent gifts
Jul 24, 2016  |  By C J Blevins
Enjoy them at home but also send them to others. Great pecan chocolate pie.

Great Southern Pecan Pie!
Jul 16, 2016  |  By Aubrey Redmon
The Southern Pecan pie was a gift. The recipient loved it.

My favorite dessert!
Apr 22, 2016  |  By D Rowe
Omg! The Best Pecan Pie Ever!

Classic pecan pies
Apr 11, 2016  |  By Steve
Excellent pecan and chocolate pecan pies! Made with Priester's own excellent pecans!

Great gift!
Mar 26, 2016  |  By Amanda
I ordered a traditional pecan pie for my sister in law for her birthday. The pie was delivered on time and was fresh. She loved it.

Always Most Appreciated
Mar 16, 2016  |  By earl quesenberry
Not my first time with this product. Usually given as a gift and I always receive a compliment and hearty thank-you.

wonderful gift
Mar 12, 2016  |  By Matthew Kress
Gave 2 pecan pies as a gift to a friend recovering from surgery - he said they were great and he enjoyed them. A bit expensive, but overall a very nice gift.

tasty goods!
Feb 7, 2016  |  By Erich
the only way i can describe the pecan pies is ''YUMMY'' !

Simply Delectable
Jan 22, 2016  |  By Sharon Hixson
What a wonderful addition to our Christmas dinner.

Pecan Pies
Jan 21, 2016  |  By Marilyn Wiley
The Pies were delicious!!!

Pecan Pie Gift
Jan 14, 2016  |  By Debbie
Purchased as gift: Two Pies-One Chocolate/One Old-Fashioned. Recipient stated the pies were the best they had ever eaten.
Owner Response: We are so glad they enjoyed the pies! Thank you for posting a review!

Jan 7, 2016  |  By Adoracion Lim
Best Pecan Pie in the world!
Owner Response: Thank you for your review! We sure do appreciate your business!

You never disappoint!
Jan 5, 2016  |  By Benita
I enjoy Priester's whenever I'm passing through that area. I've purchased a pecan pie for a family member before and he loved it. The last time I had one sent to a family member in New York and he raved about it. Just want to say thank! You've never disappoint me. Fresh, delicious and quality service!

Jan 3, 2016  |  By Carol
We received one of the old fashioned pies as a Christmas gift. It was the first time we had ever had one but it won't be the last. Absolutely THE BEST PECAN PIE!!

Excellent Pie!
Dec 25, 2015  |  By Elizabeth
Excellent Pie!

Awesome as usual!
Dec 18, 2015  |  By Charlene
The pies arrived promptly and were luscious tasting! (Just like everything we get from Priester's)

Excellent Product
Nov 27, 2015  |  By David Pieratos
The pecan pies were excellent and enjoyed by all for Thanksgiving. Would order again for every holiday.

Jun 24, 2015  |  By Brenda Massey
The pecan pie was a gift to my husband for Father's Day. It arrived in a very nice gift box in perfect condition. We all loved it! Delicious!

Pecan Pie
Jun 1, 2015  |  By Susan W. Doughtie
Sent this as a pick me up to a friend who had been sick. She said it was delish and her husband said it was better than his Mothers......but don't tell her!!! LOL

Mmmmm - Pies!
May 31, 2015  |  By Holly
As usual, the pies were great! They were part of a wedding rehersal dinner and went FAST.

Great Gift Item!
May 12, 2015  |  By Pamela Wallace
Had a pecan pie shipped to my mother-in-law in Missouri for Mother's Day. Her favorite pie is pecan and she raved about this one! Thanks!

Pecan Pies
Apr 15, 2015  |  By Cheryle
Amazing. Ordered both Pecan & Chocolate Pecan Pies.

pecan pie
Apr 13, 2015  |  By annetta
Excellent tasting and timely arrival. Delicious!!!!!!

Oct 6, 2014  |  By Andre'-P. Fournier
Very good! Not to sweet, but just right. I rate among the best!
Owner Response: Thank you!

The Best Pecan Pies
May 12, 2014  |  By Patricia L
These are the best pecan pies anywhere.