Key Lime Cake

SKU: 121
3 lbs. 2 oz.
$33.99 $28.89
Love key lime pie? Then you'll for sure love our key lime cake. It's one of our favorite cake creations, soft and moist with a tangy key lime glaze. Bursting with the flavor of the tropics, our Key Lime Cake only gets better with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream. This gourmet cake arrives in a gift box that we had specially designed by a local artist to create a gift as beautiful as it is tasty.


Write a review - receive 10% Off your next order!

Best Key Lime Cake Ever....
Dec 17, 2023  |  By Eric Peterson
The review title says it all, this is the very best Key Lime cake I have ever had. Having lived in Seminole, Al I used to drive up to Priester's to purchase the cake, now that I have move to Texas I have it shipped. I just love it, good job Priester's!!

Dec 6, 2023  |  By RoxAnne Uhrain
Very refreshing with so many sweet things to have start to break it up!

Key Lime Anyone?
Sep 3, 2023  |  By Gail
This cake is moist, light, not overly sweet and just the right amount of key lime! The frosting packet...adds a nice finish!

Yum-Yum Yummy
May 19, 2023  |  By Kenneth W. Collins
Absolutely great enjoyment

Nov 2, 2022  |  By Nique
This cake was Delish!! Exactly what I was looking for in a key lime pound cake. It had the texture of a homemade pound cake and the flavor of key lime. In each bite you get a burst of twain that comes from the lime and just the right amount of icing (not too much). Excellent cake, planning to order another one for the holiday.

I'm hooked!
Oct 5, 2022  |  By Denise Watson
This cake was delicious. It was everything I expected and more. I'm hooked

Outstanding Pound Cake!
Aug 29, 2021  |  By Mary Ann Wallace
My husband and I LOVE keylime pie so we decided to try Priester's keylime pound cake. Wow! Absolutely perfect taste and balance of true keylime flavor with delicious pound cake. We shared it with our family and they loved it too. We will be a repeat customer for sure!

Key Lime Pound Cake
Jul 2, 2021  |  By Robert Lee
Very good cake.

Great dessert!
Dec 18, 2020  |  By Michelle
We get the Key Lime Cake every year and love it! The flavor is so unique and delicious. Try it with ice cream!

Oct 16, 2019  |  By Wesley O. Boyd
This was the second Key Lime Cake I purchased from Priesters, and it was just as satisfying as the first.

Jan 6, 2019  |  By Antoinette Stinchcomb
I am always happy with my purchases from Priesters!

Key Lime Cake
Jan 5, 2019  |  By Michelle
The cake was delicious! It was moist and the flavor was perfect. If you like Key Lime, you will love this cake!

Mouth wqtering Key Lime pound cake.
Jan 5, 2019  |  By Eddie Altom
We were waiting for this to arrive as we wanted to take it with us to the family gathering for Christmas, when it got here again not waiting we opened it and had ourselves a small sample, WOW so good. We then got to thinking do we want to share this or keep it, after some thought we did take it to family night and shared, needless to say none came home, everybody raved over it. So thanks Priester's for the great cake and we will not forget it.

Best Ever
Jan 4, 2019  |  By William Bawden
My family and I have been sharing your products for Christmas for years. The service is always excellent and the product extremely and fresh.

Jan 3, 2019  |  By Allison Record
I shipped this to my parents for Christmas, as they said they had plenty of pecans frozen. They loved it. They have sliced it up and frozen it so they can eat it along the way, rather than all at one time. Could not say enough about how great it was!

Excellent Key Lime Cake
Dec 28, 2018  |  By Anita Taylor
Absolutely delicious! Exactly what I hoped for. Moist cake and the icing was yum yum.

Key Lime Cake
Dec 7, 2018  |  By Hurshel C Norman
Everyone thought this was an excellent cake. Very tasty and delicious.

Apr 22, 2018  |  By JJB
This cake is a favorite. We purchase it for family and as a corporate gift... it never disappoints.

From Key Lime Nation
Dec 27, 2017  |  By Mary Olson
We live near Key West Florida, the Key Lime Pie Capital. Receiving this as a gift from friends in Northern Wisconsin, we were hesitant. But, it truly is a top rated favorite Key Lime cake by numerous family and friends down here. We will be buying some for our Northern friends soon.

The Best Key Lime Cake in the World!!!!
Dec 8, 2016  |  By Renatta Thicklin King
My family and I have tried several key lime cakes but none compare to Priester's key lime cake, it always arrives on time and is always delicious. I have already purchased two for the holidays. We don't mind sharing the cake but once it's sampled, there is always a request for another piece. I will always purchase my key lime cake from Priester's.

A Favorite!
Apr 26, 2016  |  By J Julian-Breig
The Key Lime Cake gets rave reviews every time we send (or receive) it as a gift. Always moist. Always delicious.

Green & Great
Feb 28, 2016  |  By Phil Wehrheim
An absolute treat !

Jan 22, 2016  |  By Cathy
Just the most delicious cake I've ever tasted. Received it as a gift via mail. So moist and flavorful in a nice tin.

Key Lime Cake
Apr 24, 2015  |  By Wesley
I ordered a key lime cake to be delivered on or near May 7. It was delivered much earlier but in good condition. Having already sampled it, I can attest that it is delicious.

Key Lime Cake
Apr 15, 2015  |  By Cheryle
The Key Lime Cake has wonderful flavor.

Feb 5, 2015  |  By Debi
I too have ordered this cake many times and have even referred my old employer to order them as client gifts ... and ALWAYS, everyone has LOVED, LOVED, LOVED Priester's Key Lime Cake!!!
Owner Response: Thank you so much for the review and for referring them as client gifts! We appreciate your business!

Best cake I have ever ordered!
Nov 11, 2014  |  By Carrie
I have ordered this cake many times over the years and it is consistently moist and delicious. I have recommended it to others and they love it as well. You won't be disappointed.
Owner Response: Thank you, Carrie! We appreciate your review and are so glad that you enjoy our Keylime Cake!