Baked Goods
  • Mini Pecan Pies

    4.9 star rating
    $29.99–$59.99
    Mini pecan pies boast the same irresistible taste as our standard-sized pies in a smaller crust. Light appetite?...
  • $27.99
    A delightful Southern tradition with Betsy's Cheese Straws, handcrafted by Priester's using generations-old recipes...
  • $48.99
    Discover a Pecan Fruitcake like no other when you choose Priester's. Our time-honored recipe passed down through...
  • Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies

    5 star rating
    $27.99–$137.99
    Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are a timeless dessert that embodies the essence of Southern cooking. Made with love...
  • $27.99
    Indulge in the irresistible crunch of Priester's Betsy's Pecan Cheese Straws Gift Tin, a gourmet treat that combines...
  • $21.99–$42.99
    Want more of a good thing? Our economy-sized Priester's candy and pecan items are bulk packaged in clear, stay-fresh...
  • Chocolate Pecan Pie

    4.8 star rating
    $29.99–$137.99
    For a different spin on our old-fashioned pecan pie... 
  • New!
    $12.99
    Old Fashioned Gourmet Lemon Crisp Cookies Gourmet cookies like Betsy's Gourmet Lemon Crisps are a matc... 
  • New!

    Ginger Snap Cookies

    5 star rating
    $13.99
    Ginger Snap Cookies. Get ready for the spicy-sweet crunch of our old fashioned Ginger Snap Cookies! Th... 
  • $33.99
    Enjoy a classic, crunchy Southern treat with the Priester's Cheese Straws Gift Box Assortment. It's the perfect snack...
  • Key Lime Cake

    5 star rating
    $33.99
    Love key lime pie? Then you'll for sure love our key lime cake. It's one of our favorite cake creations, soft and...
  • $36.99
    Our Priester's signature red gift box arrives with six of our baker's favorite goodies, including Bravo Brownies,...
  • $27.99
    Our hot cheese straw is the perfect balance of heat and cheddar cheese. We used a blend of cayenne, crushed red...
  • $31.99
    Not perfect looking, but completely tasty! The crusts and filling on these 3" Mini Pecan Pies have a few flaws so...
We offer a delicious selection of baked goods for holidays, birthdays, parties, or your next event. Choose from old-fashioned pecan pies, chocolate pecan pies, and mini pecan pies made from our traditional recipe. These classic desserts are available in multiple packaging options, including individual pies, boxes of 2, and boxes of 6. You can mix and match your favorites. We also have munchable snacks like Betsy's Cheese Straws in classic, hot classic, blue cheese, and pecan flavors. Get them delivered right to your doorstep or send them to family, friends, clients, and more.